Bookstore Gallery Auctions Blog Editions VisualServer
 
BEST OF 2012
BEST OF 2011
BEST OF 2010
BEST OF 2009
BACK TO BLOG HOME f.a.q.mastheadinquiriesfeedbackadvertisenewsletter
back
back
Is Pull My Daisy Holy?
view comments [5]
by John Cohen, published on August 8th, 2008
Font Size: T T T | print | email
Robert Frank Pull My Daisy
Photography by Robert Frank.
Narration by Jack Kerouac for the film by Robert Frank and Alfred Leslie.
Introduction by Jerry Tallmer.
Steidl / The Robert Frank Project, Göttingen, 2008. Clothbound. 68 pp., 53 tritone illustrations, 5½x8". $27.50
Pull My Daisy by Robert Frank, published by Steidl, 2008
Steidl has just reissued a little book, Pull My Daisy, loaded with photographic power, a document from a phase in Robert Frank�s long career when Robert abandoned still photography to make his first film. It is strangely appropriate that Robert�s film would be about the Beat Generation, which was at the cultural cutting edge at that time.

In January 1959 Robert Frank and Alfred Leslie started production on Pull My Daisy. It was a defining moment for Robert: a statement of an artist continuing along his own path, seemingly changing horses in midstream. His book of photographs The Americans had just been published the year before. As a still photographer, Robert had previous directorial experience working with models and settings for assignments and advertising work in the magazines. He had also started a few experimental personal short films.

Pull My Daisy brought together neighbors and painters from the local downtown art world who had agreed to perform in a scene from a Jack Kerouac play (the Beat Generation which was never produced). It was an odd mixture of beat poets, Allen Ginsberg, Gregory Corso, and Peter Orlovsky, who played themselves, and painters such as Larry Rivers playing Neal Cassady (Milo), his wife Carolyn played by �Beltiane� who in reality was a famous European actress Delphine Seyrig (�Last Year At Marienbad�). Others in the cast included the Bishop �Mooney Peebles,� really Dick Bellamy, an artist�s dealer and gallery director, the bishop�s mother played by Alice Neel, a painter, the Bishop�s sister played by Sally Gross, a dancer, musician David Amram playing jazz legend Mezz McGillicuddy, and a touching appearance by Robert Frank�s little son Pablo. After the film was edited, Jack Kerouac came in and recorded a voice-over narration � which is a classic in spontaneous improvisation.

Kerouac�s narration was done in three takes, one for each ten-minute segment (reel) of the film. It was a creative leaping from inner thoughts to descriptions of action, to quotes from poets, comments on his poet friends and a discourse on religion��What is holy? Is baseball holy? Is a cockroach holy? Holy, holy!� Robert Frank said, �sometimes the camera illustrates Kerouac�s text, sometimes it is Kerouac who comments on the images.�

Over the years, the film has developed a reputation as spontaneous filmmaking, unplanned, undirected, improvised, and it does affect the viewer this way, topped off and guided by Kerouac�s poetic prose narration. But in actuality the film was planned deliberately and directed by Alfred Leslie and Robert Frank. The problem was how to get the �actors� to follow directions. All they wanted to do was clown around mess things up. David Amram recalls that although Robert was serious with the filming, �we were doing all we could to make him laugh.� Although there were scenes, actions and continuity to be covered and a script to be followed, Alfred Leslie�s directions could be barely heard over the din. But it was Robert who worked seriously composing his camera shots, camera angles, 360-degree pans around the room. Sometimes it seemed as if he was tolerating the actors rather than directing them. If this was the �spontaneous� aspect, then the real structuring, discipline and controlled shaping took place in the editing, where the shots and sequences were assembled and the inner life (rhythm) of the film took its form, following the completed filming. It was after this phase that Kerouac improvised his narration.

Robert Frank with Alfred Leslie and Gregory Corso, photograph by John Cohen, courtesy of the Deborah Bell Gallery.
Robert had asked me to take photographs of the entire production, so I witnessed all the actions, improvisations, clowning and serious efforts to keep to a script. I also photographed the closing party which was attended by art world luminaries, critics, actors, and Life Magazine which was desperate for a way to show the Beat Generation poets to a national readership (Life goes to a beat party). Life magazine was allowed to the party only if they provided the booze and refreshments. They asked me to cover (photograph) it as an assignment for them. Robert told me not to accept their offer, but instead to photograph it for myself and then lease them the �first look� rights on a weekly basis. I didn�t know I had this power� and eventually accumulated enough �rent payments� from Life to finance my own excursion to photograph and record music in east Kentucky later that year.

In those days there were few venues for independent film� the phrase hardly existed. There was one film series, Cinema 16, in NYC at that time, and the New Yorker Theater did occasional screening of non �mainstream stuff. Pull My Daisy premiered there later that year.

In 1961 Grove Press issued a small size 60 page book called Pull My Daisy, consisting largely of 16 mm stills from the film itself, as well as Jack Kerouac�s narration, both as a text and as titles beneath the images. There was an intro by Jerry Tallmer, and a few of my production photos were scattered throughout. That book has been out of print for more than forty years, even as the fame and influence of the film created its own artistic legend.

In summer of 1960, Jonas Mekas�s magazine Film Culture connected the French New Wave (Nouvelle Vague) to the New American Cinema, and Pull My Daisy played a significant role in that article along with Come Back, Africa, On the Bowery and John Cassavetes 1959 film Shadows. Mekas wrote, �Daisy is not a film of plot, action or logical statement� [It is] the only truly beat film if there is one. . . an expression of the new generation�s unconscious and spontaneous rejection of the middle class way. It is � despite its apparent robe of nonsense, the most truthful American film. There is no lie, no pretension, no moralizing in it.�

About 13 years ago (1995), in conjunction with a Whitney Museum retrospective on Beat Generation art (Beat Culture and the New America, 1950-65), a curator contacted me about doing a book about Pull My Daisy, using many of my production stills. I asked Robert Frank his thoughts on this, and he was totally not in favor. He said the book he had already done for Grove was just fine, and nothing needed to be added. I was impressed by his deep sense of conviction on this. The little book, then 30 years out of print, was the authentic statement, document and presentation, done at the time of the film. Anything else would be after the fact, interpretation, with historical significance and critical comments added.

It is wonderful that Steidl has chosen to re-publish the Pull My Daisy book now, in its original form (with a few subtle elegant design changes). It�s the real thing, the source, as it was intended, an authentic document of a work of art. Robert Frank�s first film.

[note from the editor: The fact that John Cohen took some of the photographs included in Pull My Daisy would normally keep us from publishing the above text as a review. However, in light of Cohen's relative distance from the publication of the book, and the way in which he address said book, we feel the classification is justified.]
John Cohen is a photographer, film maker, musician, artist & ex- professor at SUNY Purchase. His photographs are at the Metropolitan Museum, National Gallery, MOMA etc. His photography books include There Is No Eye and Young Bob (Powerhouse). He's made 15 film documentaries about traditional music- shown on PBS & BBC and at festivals world-wide, including 7 at the Margaret Mead Film Festival. His first film The High Lonesome Sound is still in distribution after 40 years ( Shanachie ). He is best known as musician with the New Lost City Ramblers for the past fifty years, with at least 25 recordings, Grammy nominations etc.
comments
No one has commented on this review yet, be the first to add a comment.
ADD A COMMENT


NOTE: Comments will not appear until they have been approved by our editors. Read more about our policy regarding comments.

One of our chief goals with photo-eye Magazine is to create a space where intelligent dialog about photography books can flourish. As such, we are excited about engaging directly with our readers and the larger online photo-community through interactive content such as these article comments. However, to best acheive an interesting, ongoing discourse, all comments will be published only after they have been vetted by the editors.

We will not edit anything that is posted, nor reject any comment because we disagree with it, we simply reserve the right to reject comments that we feel do not make a contribution or are designed to offend. All we ask is that comments are thoughtful and substantive.

Thank you.
* indicates a required field

Your Name/Pseudonym: *
please enter a name

Your Email: *
please enter an valid email addressplease enter an email address
This is for contact / verification only, your email will not be displayed or given out under any circumstances.

Your website:
must be a vaild URL (ex. http://www.yourwebsite.com)

Your Comment: *

please enter a comment

To help prevent auto-spamming
Please enter the text and/or numbers below, in order, left to right:
enter text from the image below



← Return to the Magazine front page
← Return to reviews
© photo-eye Magazine. This article is printed from photo-eye Magazine (http://www.photoeye.com/magazine/) and is intended for personal use. Please contact us if you would like permission to reprint this article for commercial or educational use. Text © by the author, all images © their respective owners. All rights reserved.
© PHOTO-EYE, LLC, 2022. All Rights Reserved Copyrights-Trademarks Privacy Policy Returns Policy Staff/Hours/Location 505.988.5152 info@photoeye.com