Bookstore Gallery Auctions Blog Editions VisualServer
 
BEST OF 2012
BEST OF 2011
BEST OF 2010
BEST OF 2009
BACK TO BLOG HOME f.a.q.mastheadinquiriesfeedbackadvertisenewsletter
back
back
Carrara
view comments [5]
Reviewed by George Slade, published on Tuesday, March 30, 2010
Font Size: T T T | print | email
William Wylie Carrara
Photographs by William Wylie
Center for American Places, Chicago, 2009. Hardbound. 84 pp., 56 color plates, 11-3/4x11".
Carrara Photographs by William Wylie Published by Center for American Places, 2009.
The spirit of pietra viva guides this volume. �Living stone� � an oxymoron, but one uniquely descriptive of Italian marble and of the photographs created by William Wylie over six years in the Cava di Gioia quarry. Furthering the language lesson, gioia here should be translated as �joy, delight,� as in a quarry (cava) of pleasures. There are many to be found in this lovely book, certainly one of the sleepers of 2009.

Carrara, by William Wylie. Published by Center for American Places, 2009.


Wylie�s exploration of the Carrara marble extraction business is a paean to that odd notion of living stone. His own comments are eloquent and simple, and offer a very tangible sense of the artist�s life in these great geometric bites taken out of the Italian mountainsides. Just as sculptors like Michelangelo and Henry Moore found living forms within rock taken from this place, so has Wylie found material for photographs. Like Michelangelo, his vision alights on the cavatori, the men who make their livelihood transforming mountains into building blocks and who, in the photographs, tread a line between their rough-hewn real lives, in which anything made of marble would probably seem ridiculously exorbitant, and their god-like positions as cutters of stone, caked with marble powder that renders them part of it (I wonder what a chemical analysis of their bodies shows, how much marble have they absorbed over time � are they living stone?). Like Moore, he sees Platonic, modernist forms arising within the blocks themselves, and in the transformation wrought upon the mountains in pursuit of this desirable stone, a medium that has so often been brought to life by great artists.

Carrara, by William Wylie. Published by Center for American Places, 2009.

Carrara, by William Wylie. Published by Center for American Places, 2009.



Essayist Eric Scigliano, descended from cavatori, claims that �staring too closely [at the quarry�s rock faces] can induce a wave of vertigo,� a claim borne out in the photographs. It is stunning, and disorienting, to regard this cumulative act of alpine dismantling, to see Wylie�s long views of the surrounding mountains and imagine the living stone within each peak. Carrara is an instructive and evocative book, well executed to learn from and get lost within. —George Slade

purchase book
George Slade is a photography writer, curator, historian, and consultant based in St. Paul, Minnesota. He can be found on-line at http://rephotographica-slade.blogspot.com/.
comments
No one has commented on this review yet, be the first to add a comment.
ADD A COMMENT


NOTE: Comments will not appear until they have been approved by our editors. Read more about our policy regarding comments.

One of our chief goals with photo-eye Magazine is to create a space where intelligent dialog about photography books can flourish. As such, we are excited about engaging directly with our readers and the larger online photo-community through interactive content such as these article comments. However, to best acheive an interesting, ongoing discourse, all comments will be published only after they have been vetted by the editors.

We will not edit anything that is posted, nor reject any comment because we disagree with it, we simply reserve the right to reject comments that we feel do not make a contribution or are designed to offend. All we ask is that comments are thoughtful and substantive.

Thank you.
* indicates a required field

Your Name/Pseudonym: *
please enter a name

Your Email: *
please enter an valid email addressplease enter an email address
This is for contact / verification only, your email will not be displayed or given out under any circumstances.

Your website:
must be a vaild URL (ex. http://www.yourwebsite.com)

Your Comment: *

please enter a comment

To help prevent auto-spamming
Please enter the text and/or numbers below, in order, left to right:
enter text from the image below



← Return to the Magazine front page
← Return to reviews
© photo-eye Magazine. This article is printed from photo-eye Magazine (http://www.photoeye.com/magazine/) and is intended for personal use. Please contact us if you would like permission to reprint this article for commercial or educational use. Text © by the author, all images © their respective owners. All rights reserved.
© PHOTO-EYE, LLC, 2022. All Rights Reserved Copyrights-Trademarks Privacy Policy Returns Policy Staff/Hours/Location 505.988.5152 info@photoeye.com